Only Murders In The Building Season 5: Cast Predictions

Hey guys! Are you as obsessed with "Only Murders in the Building" as I am? I mean, seriously, this show is pure genius! The mysteries, the characters, the humor – it's all just chef's kiss. And with Season 4 having just wrapped up with so many cliffhangers and twists, I'm already counting down the days until Season 5. Of course, the biggest question on everyone's minds is: who will be gracing our screens in the next installment? So, let's dive into some speculations and predictions about the "Only Murders in the Building" Season 5 cast!

Who's Likely to Return?

First things first, let's talk about the core trio that makes this show so special. There's absolutely no way we're not seeing Steve Martin as the lovable (and slightly eccentric) Charles-Haden Savage, Martin Short as the flamboyant Oliver Putnam, and Selena Gomez as the witty and insightful Mabel Mora. These three have such incredible chemistry, and their dynamic is the heart and soul of "Only Murders in the Building." Can you imagine the show without them? I sure can't! They've become like our best friends, solving mysteries in their iconic Upper West Side building, and we need them back for Season 5. Raiders Vs Patriots: Where To Watch The Game Live

Beyond our main trio, there are a few other characters who have become integral to the Arconia's world and the show's overall charm. We can definitely expect to see more of Michael Cyril Creighton as Howard Morris, the cat-loving, conspiracy-theorizing neighbor who always seems to be in the middle of everything. His quirky personality and hilarious one-liners are a constant source of amusement. And what about Da'Vine Joy Randolph as Detective Donna Williams? She brings a much-needed dose of skepticism and groundedness to the group's amateur sleuthing, and her interactions with Charles, Oliver, and Mabel are always gold. Plus, let's not forget about Tina Fey as the true-crime podcast mogul, Cindy Canning. Her character adds a layer of meta-commentary to the show, and her competitive spirit with our podcasters is always entertaining. These supporting players add so much depth and humor to the series, and their return in Season 5 would be more than welcome.

New Faces and Potential Guest Stars

Now, this is where things get really exciting! "Only Murders in the Building" is known for its stellar guest stars, and each season brings in new characters who add fresh dynamics and potential suspects to the mix. Season 4 had some incredible additions, and I'm sure Season 5 will be no different. Who could we see joining the Arconia's residents in their next investigation? This is where the speculation begins!

One thing that "Only Murders in the Building" does incredibly well is casting actors who bring both comedic timing and dramatic depth to their roles. Think about Nathan Lane as Teddy Dimas, or Jane Lynch as Sazz Pataki – these are actors who can make you laugh one minute and break your heart the next. So, when we're thinking about potential guest stars, we need to look for performers who have that same range. Could we see a comedic legend like Bill Murray or Steve Carell joining the cast? Imagine the hilarious scenarios they could bring to the table! Or perhaps a dramatic powerhouse like Laura Linney or Bryan Cranston could add a layer of intensity and intrigue to the mystery. The possibilities are endless!

Of course, "Only Murders in the Building" also has a knack for casting actors who are perfect for specific roles, even if they're not necessarily household names. Remember James Caverly as Theo Dimas? He was absolutely brilliant in his role, and his performance was both nuanced and compelling. So, it's entirely possible that Season 5 will introduce us to some new faces who will quickly become fan favorites. Maybe we'll see a rising star from the world of theater or independent film, or perhaps a comedian who's just waiting for their breakout role. The casting directors for this show are clearly geniuses, so I have no doubt they'll find some amazing talent to join the cast.

Characters We'd Love to See More Of

While new faces are always exciting, there are also some past characters that I'd love to see make a comeback in Season 5. One character that immediately springs to mind is Jayne Houdyshell as Bunny Folger. Okay, I know, I know – she's, uh, no longer with us. But hear me out! "Only Murders in the Building" loves flashbacks and dream sequences, and Bunny was such a pivotal character in the first two seasons. Plus, Jayne Houdyshell is just phenomenal, and any excuse to have her back on screen would be a win in my book. Maybe we could see her in a ghostly form, offering cryptic clues to our trio? Or perhaps we'll get a deeper dive into her backstory and her connection to the Arconia.

Another character I'd love to see return is Amy Schumer as herself. Her brief appearance in Season 2 was hilarious, and her obsession with turning the "Only Murders in the Building" podcast into a TV show was a great meta-joke. It would be fun to see her back in Season 5, perhaps actually trying to produce a fictionalized version of the podcast. Imagine the comedic possibilities! And what about Cara Delevingne as Alice Banks? Her relationship with Mabel was intriguing, and her art world connections could definitely come into play in a future mystery. Plus, Cara Delevingne is just so charismatic on screen, and I'd love to see her character explored further. Texans Vs Buccaneers: Clash Of The Titans

Predicting the New Victim and Suspects

Okay, let's get down to the nitty-gritty: who's going to be the next victim in Season 5, and who are the potential suspects? This is the fun part, right? "Only Murders in the Building" is a masterclass in misdirection, and the writers are experts at throwing red herrings and surprising us with unexpected twists. So, predicting the victim and the killer is always a challenge, but that's what makes it so much fun!

Based on the way Season 4 ended, there are a few potential victims that come to mind. Of course, the show could throw us a curveball and introduce a completely new character who ends up meeting an untimely end. But if we're looking at existing characters, there are a few who seem particularly vulnerable. Maybe it's someone connected to the latest case, or perhaps it's a character who has a secret that they're desperately trying to protect. The possibilities are endless!

As for the suspects, that's even trickier to predict. "Only Murders in the Building" loves to make us suspect everyone, and the show is brilliant at planting seeds of doubt and creating compelling motives for multiple characters. Maybe the killer is someone we've already met, or perhaps it's a brand new character who's hiding a dark secret. One thing's for sure: the writers will keep us guessing until the very end. Tarzgrace OnlyFans Leak: What You Should Know

My Season 5 Cast Wishlist

Alright, guys, it's time for my personal wishlist for the "Only Murders in the Building" Season 5 cast. If I could handpick the actors who will be joining the Arconia's residents in their next adventure, here's who I'd choose:

  • Bill Murray: I mentioned him earlier, but I truly think Bill Murray would be perfect for this show. His comedic timing is impeccable, and he has a way of playing eccentric characters that would fit right in with the Arconia's quirky residents.
  • Laura Linney: Laura Linney is a phenomenal actress, and she can bring so much depth and intensity to any role. I'd love to see her play a character with a dark secret or a hidden agenda. Imagine the possibilities!
  • Oscar Isaac: Oscar Isaac is another actor who can seamlessly blend humor and drama, and he has a way of making even the most morally ambiguous characters sympathetic. I think he'd be a fantastic addition to the "Only Murders in the Building" universe.
  • Maya Rudolph: Maya Rudolph is a comedic genius, and she's also a fantastic dramatic actress. I'd love to see her play a character who's both hilarious and heartbreaking. Plus, her chemistry with Martin Short would be off the charts!

Of course, this is just my wishlist, and the actual cast of Season 5 will likely be a surprise. But hey, a girl can dream, right? No matter who ends up joining the cast, I'm confident that "Only Murders in the Building" Season 5 will be another must-watch installment in this brilliant series.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it – my predictions and speculations about the "Only Murders in the Building" Season 5 cast. Who do you guys think will be joining the show? Are there any actors you'd love to see make an appearance? Let me know in the comments below! And in the meantime, let's all keep our fingers crossed that Season 5 arrives sooner rather than later. I can't wait to see what mysteries Charles, Oliver, and Mabel will be solving next! This show has truly captured our hearts with its clever writing, brilliant performances, and captivating mysteries. The anticipation for Season 5 is already building, and I'm sure it will be another season filled with twists, turns, and plenty of laughs. The cast is a crucial part of what makes "Only Murders in the Building" so special, and I'm excited to see who will be joining the Arconia family next. The dynamic between the characters, both old and new, is what drives the show's unique charm and keeps us coming back for more. Whether it's the core trio's hilarious banter or the intriguing secrets of the supporting cast, every character adds a layer of depth to the story. And with the show's knack for casting unexpected guest stars, the possibilities for Season 5 are truly endless. So, let's keep the speculation going and get ready for another thrilling season of "Only Murders in the Building"!

Photo of Kim Anderson

Kim Anderson

Executive Director ·

Experienced Executive with a demonstrated history of managing large teams, budgets, and diverse programs across the legislative, policy, political, organizing, communications, partnerships, and training areas.