Ed Gein's Brother: Did He Do It?

Hey guys, ever heard of Ed Gein? This dude is like, the poster child for all things creepy and messed up. We're talking about a guy who dug up graves, made furniture out of human remains, and generally gave everyone the serious heebie-jeebies. But there's a lesser-known part of his story that's always been a source of debate: did Ed Gein kill his brother, Henry Gein? It’s a complicated question, and the answer, as you might guess, isn't exactly a straight-up yes or no. Let's dive in and unravel this bizarre tale together, shall we?

The Mysterious Death of Henry Gein

Okay, so here's the deal. Back in 1944, Ed Gein and his brother Henry were working in the marshland near their farm in Plainfield, Wisconsin. They were burning some brush when a fire got out of control. As they tried to put it out, the brothers separated. Ed eventually led the authorities to Henry, who was found dead. Henry had been missing for some time. The official cause of death was listed as asphyxiation, but the circumstances surrounding Henry's demise are super sketchy, and raise some serious red flags, that would be the turning point of Ed’s already weird life. What happened out there in the marshland? Was it an accident, or did something more sinister occur?

The official story is that Henry got lost in the fire and smoke, and the smoke eventually got to him. However, some people have suggested that Ed may have been responsible. There are a couple of key details that make this theory more plausible. Firstly, when the authorities found Henry’s body, it was found with head injuries. Secondly, Ed acted in a way that suggested guilt and that he was hiding something, and it was at this point that he began to show some serious signs of mental instability. He had always been an odd duck, but his behavior after his brother’s death was off the charts.

The Evidence (and the Lack Thereof)

So, what kind of evidence do we have to work with? Well, not a whole heck of a lot, honestly. The case was investigated, but it wasn't treated as a murder investigation. The authorities concluded that Henry's death was accidental. There were no charges brought against Ed Gein related to his brother's death. There was no forensic evidence that definitively proved Ed Gein killed his brother. There were no witnesses. So it’s all based on circumstantial evidence, which is the weakest type of evidence in any case.

However, there were a few things that made people suspicious. Ed Gein was the last person to see Henry alive, and he was the one who led the authorities to his body. Also, there are reports that he seemed strangely calm, and didn’t display any signs of the grief you might expect from someone who had just lost their brother. Plus, as we will see, Ed Gein was a pretty disturbed individual, so it's not totally out of the realm of possibility that he could have been involved in his brother’s death. Sevilla Vs Elche CF: La Liga Showdown

Ed Gein's Troubled History

Now, let's talk a bit about Ed Gein himself. Because to understand the possibility of him killing his brother, you've got to understand what a messed-up dude he was. Ed Gein had a seriously troubled childhood. His mother, Augusta, was a deeply religious and controlling woman who basically ran the show. She was extremely critical of Ed and his brother, and she isolated them from the outside world. She preached to them about the evils of the world, the wickedness of women, and the importance of the bible.

After his father died in 1940, Ed and Henry were left alone with their mother. Henry was the more outgoing and social of the two brothers. He was also starting to get involved in relationships, something Augusta disapproved of. The Gein brothers stayed home and kept their mother company until she passed away in 1945. This, some people speculate, drove Ed over the edge, and may have led to the murder of his brother.

Ed Gein's fascination with death began around this time. He started reading about anatomy and human dissection. It was after his mother’s death that he began visiting local cemeteries at night, where he exhumed corpses from graves, and took body parts and other items to take back home. He kept the body parts at his home, and used them to make furniture, clothing, and other macabre items. This is not the behavior of a well-adjusted individual, and this is a major reason why it is thought that Ed Gein killed his brother. Dominion Power Outage Causes Impacts And Solutions

The Theories: Accident or Murder?

So, here's where things get interesting. Was Henry's death a tragic accident, or was something more sinister at play? Here are the main theories: Remembering 9/11: The Moment Of Silence & Its Significance

  • Accidental Death: The official explanation is that Henry died in the fire and smoke. It's possible that he got disoriented, or that the fire consumed him. This is the simplest explanation, and the one supported by the official investigation.
  • Murder: Some people believe that Ed killed his brother. The head injuries are suspicious. The fact that Ed was the last person with Henry, and his subsequent behavior, certainly fuels this theory. Maybe it was an argument that turned violent, or maybe Ed had planned it all along. This would also be the point where Ed's life took a turn for the worse.

The Verdict

So, did Ed Gein kill his brother? Sadly, there's no definitive answer. The lack of concrete evidence means we're left with a lot of speculation. However, considering Ed Gein's deeply disturbed background, his strange behavior after Henry's death, and the mysterious circumstances surrounding the fire, it's certainly possible that he was involved. It's a grim and unsettling thought, but it's a part of the Ed Gein story that we can’t ignore.

Ultimately, the truth of what happened in the marshland back in 1944 remains a mystery. It's a chilling reminder that even within the already bizarre story of Ed Gein, there are layers of darkness and unanswered questions. This is a case that will continue to fascinate and disturb us for years to come.

Photo of Kim Anderson

Kim Anderson

Executive Director ·

Experienced Executive with a demonstrated history of managing large teams, budgets, and diverse programs across the legislative, policy, political, organizing, communications, partnerships, and training areas.